Wannabe Recipea: Goldfish Crackers

IMG_7328-2

Lulu might be taking her self-imposed lessons in empathy a little too far.

Yesterday she sat in her baby doll stroller and rolled herself around the house, claiming to be in a wheelchair.  I was going to put a kibosh on her game as being insensitive, but it came to a crashing end all on its own.  Let’s just say our stairway is not up to ADA standards.

Today she’s pretending that a pair of blue Minnie Mouse sunglasses are actual eyeglasses and that she “can’t see a thing without them.”  She’s walking around squinting, taking off her frames and rubbing her eyes like they are so fatigued from trying to see.  She’s gone as far as giving herself pretend eye exams:  “Do you like 1 or 2?”  How about now?  1…or 2?”

The most alarming part of this whole game was when she removed the glasses, looked me up and down, in my jeans, T-shirt and unkempt hair and said, “Mom, I love you no matter what you look like.”

She says the sweetest things.  I liked it better when she couldn’t see.

Especially at snack time.

IMG_7329-2

Goldfish Crackers

*gluten and dairy-free

Makes approximately 4 1/2 c. of crackers

Print this recipe!

  • 1 c. all-purpose gluten-free flour (i.e. Bob’s Red Mill)
  • 1 c. garbanzo bean flour
  • 3/4 t. xanthan gum
  • 1 t. salt
  • 1/4 t. dry mustard
  • 1 c. non-dairy cheddar cheese (i.e. Daiya)
  • 1/2 c. vegan margarine (i.e. Earth Balance)
  • 5 T. cold water

IMG_7279

Note: if you’d like to make a non-gluten free version, use 1 c. whole wheat pastry flour and 1 c. unbleached all-purpose flour and omit xanthan gum.

In the pitcher of a high speed blender or the bowl of a food processor, combine flours, xanthan gum, salt and mustard.

IMG_7281

Pulse to combine.  Add cheese and pulse again until fully incorporated.

IMG_7286

IMG_7288

Add margarine in small chunks and pulse, cutting it into the cheese flour.

IMG_7289

Transfer the mixture to a large bowl.

IMG_7291

Add water, one tablespoon at a time, stirring until a dough forms.

IMG_7292

IMG_7296

Transfer dough to a large piece of plastic wrap, form into a circle, wrap up and refrigerate for at least an hour.

IMG_7297

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

Using a floured pin and board (gluten free all purpose flour is fine for these purposes too), roll dough out to about 1/4 –1/2 inch thick.

IMG_7298

Cut crackers out using cookie cutters and carefully transfer to a baking sheet lined with parchment paper or a Silpat.

IMG_7302

IMG_7306

If you want to save time, or have children who are pretending to be visually impaired, you can simply cut the dough into squares and make an imprint with the end of a spoon or fork.

IMG_7309

Instant Cheez-Its.

Bake for 10-14 minutes, until crackers are crisp and golden.  Allow to cool before transferring to an airtight container.

IMG_7322-2

They taste like goldfish.  Salty, crunchy and deliciously cheesy.

IMG_7325-2

They look like goldfish.  Especially through a pair of cheap, child’s sunglasses.

IMG_7330-2

You can make whatever shape you like, depending on your audience.  I tried puppies, of course, but the pesky tail kept coming off.

Hence the squares.  Cheez-Its don’t have tails.

IMG_7340-2

The point is, these are tasty.  They’re worth every extra bit of effort for your kiddos, even if you don’t have goldfish cookie cutters.

After all, as a wise blind woman once said, you’ll love them no matter what they look like.

Amen.

  1. ….. IS THIS A JOKE.

    Yum. tastic.

    That’s all I have to say about that.

  2. Yes, please! Those look great. Too bad my pantry is overflowing with crackers from holidays. Can I justify making these?

  3. You are a goddess! I can’t wait to make this. If you only knew how many bags (cough Costco tubs) of Goldfish I consumed in college…

  4. Ashley says:

    Oooooh… Yum.

    Do you think the mustard is a necessity? That is on our “list” right now of nono’s. And do you think I could use coconut oil vs. margarine? Our list is so long there is something in every recipe I have to change, but this one is close!

    Thanks!

    • MamaPea says:

      Both good questions…yes, I think you could omit the mustard. I contemplated using the coconut oil, but I thought it would impart that coconut flavor. But the cheddar might mask it. You might also try adding another spice to make up for the mustard…maybe garlic powder or even a little cayenne?

  5. Awesome! Can’t wait to try this recipe!

    Kids say the darndest things: the other night I was putting my daughter to bed and she said something smelled good. She said it was my breathe, and that it smelled like gramma’s. Hmmm…

  6. Oh these sound perfect! Definitely on my list of things to make soon! I make a rosemary cracker that I can’t seem to keep in the house for long enough to take pictures of. I guess that’s a good sign.

  7. Amanda says:

    YAY! I can’t wait to try these. I still haven’t tried garbanzo flour in my baking.

  8. KT says:

    AAGH These are adorable!! Random question but…if you’re making them non-gluten free do you think the xanthan gum would still be necessary?

  9. These look amazing! I’m definitely going to make these for my 3 year old neice and my 1 year old nephew. I’m sure at least one of them will eat them! ;)

  10. I am SO excited to make these for my little guy. We just picked up a set of fun cookie cutters at Target today with the intention of making gluten-free crackers. This recipe will be perfect!

  11. Lou says:

    These look great – I’ve never tried a goldfish cracker though. Why would you want to eat a goldfish?

  12. Melaina says:

    This post is so cute and hilarious that I just have to make these! My stomach doesn’t greatly agree with Diaya, even though it is delicious! Do you think I could use a soy based cheese instead with the same result?? Thanks!

  13. Misty Griffin says:

    I STILL haven’t found your cookbook…I think the movers stole it…I’ll be making a pilgrimage to B&N tomorrow….cannot live without it any longer! (it’s been 2 weeks)

  14. These are so adorable! Lucky daughters you have.

  15. I love these! I used to have one of those Goldfish car carriers that I’d bring along on car trips. I can’t wait to make some of these and relive those childhood memories healthier this time around! :D

  16. Hiding this from the husband. He’ll demand these.
    P.S. It’s official: i’ll be in the PDX for about a week the last week in March :)

  17. Brandy says:

    I’ve been dying for dairy free goldfish! DS always makes a sad face at them in the store, he’s allergic to dairy . . . so it’s really fun. :( Actually, not even close to fun. I still need to find someplace close that has the dairy free cheese, apparently people here don’t know such a thing exists. Pashaw! Get with the vegan times! :) And the instant cheez-its? LOVE ‘EM!

  18. YUM! Definitely making these for D’s 2nd birthday party next month. Thanks :)

  19. haha i started laughing out loud at her saying she loves you no matter what you look like…let’s hope the little dude is that kind because Lord knows a shower is probably happening less often than now (which is less often than i’ll admit…)!

  20. Geneviève says:

    OMG. Thoses crakers are the things my kids missed the most since we are gluten and dairy free. They will so love me now!!! Thank you !!

  21. I could live indefinitely on cheezy crackers alone. These are so cute! I’d go the Cheez Its route, for sure, lol.

    Lulu is a riot. I’m so glad I have repressed my similar childhood experiments and burned the Polaroids that might remind me, lol. Thank goodness digital cameras didn’t exist in my day and nobody in the family owned a camcorder. Yay, square 1980s family! :)

  22. Your creations never cease to amaze me. My boys, even though they’re not toddlers would still love the goldfish crackers. I mean can you ever really out grow goldfish? Well, even if you can. Cheez-Its are for all ages………..:)

  23. Justine says:

    I love how you can make store brand dabs into ur own- hats off to u once again mama pea!

  24. Did I mention you’re my hero? Just incase I forgot….YOU’RE MY HERO! :)

  25. Oh these look wonderful. I can’t remember the last savory cracker-ish recipe you posted, maybe about 2-3 weeks ago and I remember Skylar loved whatever it was but now I can’t remember. How’s that for short term memory failure!

    But that one, whatever it was, and this one…both…need to be made, soon. I love Goldfish and CheezeIts. Big time.

  26. Amber K says:

    Yum! I used to love Goldfish. I always ate the tails first :) I’m going to have to try this sometime without xanthan gum. Now I just to decide what shape I want!

  27. These are just plain awesome. Mine would NEVER look that cute. Ha ha- your stairs are not up to ADA standards.

  28. lindsay says:

    um yes! i am all about the GF DF love. Good job mama P!

  29. Maddy says:

    Yes yes yes!!! Even as a high school student, the thought of re uniting with the infamous fishy snacks I used to love makes me giddy! Quick question… I see you say garbanzo bean flour in the recipe but there’s garbanzo fava mix in the picture, I don’t usually use them interchangeably but does that work in this recipe? Thanks!

    • MamaPea says:

      I use them interchangeably. What difference do you notice? Just curious…I’m new to the GF baking realm.

      • Maddy says:

        I just have the babycakes cookbook and it says to never try and replace one for the other in one of the recipes but that’s desserts so it might be about density etc. The crackers look delicious, i’ll give them a shot!

  30. i once saw some kids feeding koi goldfish crackers. it was so horrifying!

  31. Ali says:

    Best.Friggin.Mom.Ever.

  32. Deanna says:

    I feel like the handful of goldfish I chose to snack on right now were ill timed, and possibly don’t taste as good anymore. Possibly because a) they are not homemade and are slightly not fresh, or b) because they weren’t made with the cutest fish cookie cutter I have ever laid eyes on.

  33. Thanks for the good laugh, Lulu!

    This recipe looks amazing. Thanks for making it GF — can’t wait to try it!

  34. Heather says:

    You are brilliant! I have to try these as my boys have not had goldfish crackers in forever.

    The z bars were a huge hit. My oldest had one after his golf lessons last nigt…yay to delicious kid friendly recovery snacks!

  35. Cheoy Lee says:

    Cool, fun shapes are always a fun way to get your kids to engage a bit more with the food they’re eating. It might also later encourage them to help you out making them, entering even more into the process!

  36. Lauren says:

    You are my inspiration! I seriously hope I have enough drive to do the same things you do when I have kids. :)

  37. Simply Life says:

    oh these are so creative! love it!

  38. What a cute cookie cutter! My kids are just starting to notice shapes of things so I’ll have to hunt one of those down. They’ll love ‘em and I’m sure I will too. Thanks for the inspiration!

  39. YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Healthy gold fish!! Finally!!! These look so amazing!! Where did you ever find that little fish cutter!! Its perfect!

  40. Lulu is a character… I think it’s vlog time!

  41. i love you i love you i love you for making gluten free goodies.

    That is all.

  42. Tracey says:

    I am totally making these, along with the carrot cake, for Evelyn’s first birthday party!!!

  43. LOL what a compliment!! I’m pretty sure I would have just burst into laughter at that moment!! As soon as I saw this pop up in my reader, I wondered how you got the crackers into fish shapes that actually puffed up like the Goldfish that you’d find at the grocery store, and I think your little cookie cutter is so cute!!! Knowing me, mine would come out looking nothing like fish so I might have to go for the Cheez-it variation, but either way I can’t wait to try these!

  44. These are so stinkin’ precious! AND what an easy recipe – This may be my evening activity today :) Though I don’t have any charming fish shapes :(

  45. Forget the kids, I am going to make these for myself-LOL! I haven’t had a goldfish cracker in 5 years, or any cheesy cracker in 5 years.

    These would also be great to make for my daughter’s preschool class- one of the little ones has a severe peanut allergy but these would be a great, safe treat to share with the class.

    Thanks for sharing!

  46. Christine says:

    I want these and I don’t have kids as an excuse! :-) Wow that is dedication….homemade cheese crackers right down to the goldfish shape. Adorable! They look delish!!

    Your non-ADA compliant stairs comment made me almost wet my pants! Too funny! We just did a build out in our office and I am more familiar with these laws than I want to be.

  47. “Fish are friends, not food.” Does that count golfish crackers?

  48. haha that story about the glasses and pretending not to be able to see reminds me of that scene in A Christmas Story where Ralphy is blind and walks around with a cane while his mom fawns all over him :)

  49. Jen says:

    Oh yum. I have had a long time love of goldfish. I was just eating some last night. Trying to nix cheese has been a tad difficult. Will have to try to make these to satisfy my craving :)

  50. Libby says:

    Kids are great self-esteem killers. I once loudly announced that my mom had a moustache in the middle of a restaurant. I’m sure I’ll be getting paybacks soon. These crackers have to taste better than the original, and I’ve been wanting to try making my own crackers, so this is a great place to start!

  51. These are the cutest things in the entire world. I waaant!

  52. Kath says:

    LOL – your girls just get cuter and cuter!

  53. LeaAnn Schulz says:

    This is too funny. I have been vegetarian for about 9 months and couldn’t wait to get your cookbook because I just love your stuff! Monday I decided to go vegan and was totally tempted last night when I walked in the door to a big container of Cheez-Its (which I love). So this morning when I came into work I looked up a recipe for Vegan Gold Fish on Chef Chole’s website which I had seen before. Then I popped over to your website and look what was staring me in the face, your recipe. I think it means I need to make these tonight.

  54. Theresa says:

    These crackers look fabulous. I don’t have a fish cookie cutter, hmm but I do have a small maple leaf one. Maple leaf shaped crackers…yeah I can do that. :)

  55. Carissa says:

    I’m a sucker for homemade crackers. Who cares if they take a bunch of work compared to the bought kind? They’re much healthier & much much tastier!!

  56. I nearly died when Lulu gave herself an eye exam. She was spot-on! I’ve been wearing glasses since I was five, so I’ve certainly sat through my fair share of eye exams…

    These crackers look great! My new year’s resolution is to give gluten-free baking a try, so I might just have to give these guys a shot!

  57. Lindsey says:

    Thank you for this recipe! I’ve been trying to find a way to do GF goldfish for my daughter to take as snacks!

  58. Renee says:

    What a Creative Idea!!! Make your own and a lot healthier version too. Thanks for sharing!

  59. Kat says:

    cheezy has been my latest preggo craving – last night was broccoli cheeze soup and a quesadilla! thank you for making these GF – and for always knowing what I’m craving :)

  60. I LOVE YOUR WANNABE RECIPEAS. :)
    I wonder if using Nutritional yeast instead of Daiya would work?… (maybe it would be like the “Parmesan” flavored goldfish?)
    Unlike everyone else on the planet, I’m just not a huge Daiya fan.

  61. lyn says:

    Yum! Will have to make these! Would love it if you’d do a GF Animal Cracker too…pretty please?

  62. Kelsey says:

    Penelope is going to love these!

  63. bitt says:

    Wow I could do some serious damage on these. Good thing I don’t live in the PNW anymore or I’d be headed over.

    I could make some of these with my duck cutters to make cheesy quackers.

  64. Jackie says:

    You might have a future doctor on your hands! I think she needs Operation ;)

  65. cathy says:

    When we first moved to Florida my sister and I went to a new friends house and her mom said ” do you want some goldfish for a snack?” My sister and I had never had the crackers and we were horrifed thinking these people snacked on actual goldfish. LOL

  66. Too funny on Lulu, I remember going through a similar stage. These crackers look wonderful, I might just make them even just for myself.

  67. Melaina says:

    I made these crackers and OH MY GOODNESS! SO DELICIOUS! I made only few changes to the recipes… check it out here and I’d love your feedback! http://itreallyworksrecipes.blogspot.com/2012/01/wannabe-wheat-thins-gluten-free.html

  68. I totally love you for your gluten free ways! My daughter was a cheezit freak, this needs to happen ASAP! :)

  69. When I was little and “pretended” I couldn’t see…I actually couldn’t see. Mom didn’t believe me and took me to two different optometrists before she got me glasses!

  70. BroccoliHut says:

    Love this! My mom used to buy the jumbo-size cartons of Goldfish from Sam’s when I was a kid…that’s how much of a cheddar tooth I had. Can’t wait to try this version.

  71. They look like the perfect snack! I get nervous using gluten free flours, mine seem to never rise or come together well, but those look awesome! I need to work on my gluten free flour baking :)

  72. Your kids crack me up. “1 or 2″ Children are such good free entertainment. It is the clothing and feed part that stops me right now.

    I learned today that if I google Mama Pea you come right up. Glad to know google is on top of things even when I am confused about what I am looking for.

  73. Kayla says:

    Can’t wait to try! And cute new (?) profile pic!

  74. love this!! you are the best mom for making these goldfish crackers, homemade and healthy! you are a rockstar :)

  75. Docia says:

    Those are some interesting looking goldfish! Your kids are so cute and funny :)

  76. Kere says:

    YAY!!! A gf recipea!!! WOOHOO!
    Can’t wait to try it….I have been so hesitant to bake gf. I have all kinds of gf flour but have yet to actually put them in the mixing bowl! I am going through baking withdrawal…fearful of horrendous outcomes!

    Your girls crack me up…what fun kids!!

  77. Kathryn says:

    Thank you for providing great allergy-friendly recipes for us Moms who have children with food allergies!

  78. Mern says:

    Its funny how after being a avid reader for a year now that you making wannabe goldfish crackers didn’t even phase me; only to stop reading half way and realize “this woman just made goldfish crackers” damn or dang ( I’ll go to my swear jar later)

    Will be trying this reci-pea very soon!

  79. janetha says:

    i knew i could use that cookie cutter i got at my bachelorette party for something….

  80. I admit I was so relieved when I got to the part about cutting them into squares. But the fish are so fun! I am the only kid in my household, but still.

  81. Jes Suazo says:

    I can’t wait to try this recipe! My son loves goldfish & I love making healthy treats for him!

  82. I will probably make these with real cheese, but I am SO grateful for this recipe. Cheez-Its were always my favorite chemical-laden cracker!! :)

  83. Ana says:

    Made these yesterday and had to come back to say Thank You Mama Pea, these crackers are delicious!
    I used coconut oil (instead of earth balance) and “veggie shreds” (cheddar flavor, in place of the daya), and it worked great. Oh, I also added 1 tbsp of nutritional yeast to the dry ingredients.
    The crackers were cheesy and crispy and puffy, they were so cool and so delicious!! I cut mine into squares just because I didn’t have the cute fish cutter.
    My son loved them, and so did my husband – who came to apologize to me at night because he ate most of the crackers I made. I much prefer to see him eating the things I make at home rather than the store bought stuff, so I was as happy as could be, and totally didn’t mind seeing it all gone. Yes, because I made half batch yesterday and among the three of us we polished the whole thing of in one day, by bedtime there were no crackers left. Which is fun actually, because I love cooking and baking and now I can make more!
    Thanks again Mama Pea!
    Ana

  84. Malena says:

    I just “pinned” this recipe! You’re a genius. :) I can’t wait to make these.

  85. leah says:

    do you think you could omit the xanthan gum altogether? i’m not dairy free, so you think egg might be ok to add?

Leave A Comment